I would like to go on record in stating it is my belief that voluntary hospitalization of the epileptic is anything but desirable.
From the standpoint of rehabilitation of the epileptic, I must take into consideration the particular type of epileptic we have in the hospital. As Dr. Treadway stated, the majority of these man have not reached probably the school grade of seven years. There has been an attempt on the part of the rehabilitation department to make lawyers, doctors, diplomats out of these epileptics. It is absurd and cannot be done. These men are social and economic lepers, so far as their rehabilitation is concerned. The communities do not want them. Their families do not want them and the responsibility for their care rests upon the Government. Then what is to be the solution of the disposition of these men? I can see but probably two solutions to the question. Voluntary hospitalisation is out of the question. I believe that that part of the Bureau concerned with the compensation of these men, from an economical standpoint, must take into consideration the question of the grouping of these epileptics. There is a class which can live at home. There is another class, not definitely formidable, which does need custodial care. Then there is the psychiatric epileptic who needs psychopathic institutional care. In arriving at the disposition of these men you must take into consideration those three groups.
Then there is another group, there is a mixed group of epileptics. In many instances we have noted, after a long period of observation, that a man may react to some situation, starting out in a hysterical seizure and wind up in a definite epileptic attack. That has been true in quite a number of cases and I should like to urge upon the Bureau District officers and those concerned, this one thing:
In referring cases to East Norfolk, I think a very careful examination should be made of these men to determine as nearly as possible that they are epileptics.
At East Norfolk there is a situation existing which I have endeavored to correct; that is hospitalizing psycho-neurotics,—neuropsychiatry cases which are not definitely epileptic, which are made worse by contact with the epileptic patient. These men are being made worse every day. Some of them simulate very closely the epileptic; many have learned to bite their tongues as the epileptic does. They should not be hospitalized; about 25% of the cases are not epileptic. I think that should be taken into consideration and a careful survey made of these patients before they are transferred to East Norfolk.
As to these cases, very much the same program is carried out as Dr. Kolb’s. Complete preliminary physical and neurological examinations are made and patients are placed under observation of one man, who observes them and makes notes from time to time. As for the treatment of these men, there is little to be done in a way. I think it resolves itself into occupation mostly. I think the occupational measure as applied to the epileptic is the only solution. I think they should be kept busy every moment, for many reasons. They are naturally fault finding and if they have something to do it will lessen the time they have to think of these things. It will promote interest in their surroundings. It will lessen the liability of deterioration but as the thing now stands that cannot be done, under the present method of hospitalization. The solution covering that is, I believe, for the Government to formulate, properly taking into consideration these districts, and build an epileptic colony, under proper supervision, and I believe from an economic standpoint, it could be made almost self-supporting.
In regard to the medical treatment, we have been instituting at East Norfolk a very careful treatment,—careful observation—to determine the real value of luminol in the treatment of epilepsy and we have found that it has been beneficial in many ways; that it lessens the severity of the shock, prolongs the intervals between shocks and in many instances effects complete cessation; the patient becomes more alert, more active, more interested in his surroundings. This treatment must be continued day after day. If there is a cessation, or lack of it, or a failure or inability on our part to obtain luminol, these men immediately react to the lack of it. I should say we have had at least four deaths at East Norfolk due absolutely to the lack of luminol.
DR. WILBUR: At Chicago we developed a diagnostic clinic at the Marine Hospital and had two departments: in-patient and out-patient departments. We had a capacity for in-patients of about 150. The out-patient department was unlimited and developed to approximately 160 to 175 patients at one time. The in-patient department is divided into five groups for the investigation of cases;
1. Cases which would be immediately transferred to some other hospital as soon as arrangements could be made;
2. Certain disorders taken up under direction of an officer particularly interested in such disorders and investigated as fully as possible;