This block diagram of Telstar I’s command circuit shows the redundant receiver and decoder chains, No. 1 and No. 2, which are fed the command signals from the ground that are picked up by the VHF antenna. Decoded instructions go to the command switching control, which operates relays to turn equipment on or off. Reports on the operation of this control are sent back by telemetry to the ground station along with information from the satellite’s sensors.

VHF antenna diplexer command receiver No. 1 command decoder No. 1 T1 command command receiver No. 2 command decoder No. 2 T2 command command switching control (operates relays) S-SS relay D-DD relay other relays 136-mc beacon transmitter SS open S close telemetry DD open SS open D close sensors (radiation detectors, particle counters, solar aspect cells, thermistors, etc.) power supply solar cell power plant storage battery power plant SS open S close through other relays to communications circuits and orientation torque coil

What Went Wrong With Telstar I

During Telstar I’s first two months in orbit, the only indication of trouble cropped up in one of the command operations. Telemetry told us that the satellite was no longer executing the T2 command. This meant that we could not temporarily disconnect command chain No. 1 to check the performance of chain No. 2. Then, a short while later, No. 2 began to give intermittent operation. Finally it failed completely. At the time, we didn’t know why this had happened, but, since the satellite’s other command chain still seemed to be operating normally, we were not very worried.

However, in the middle of November 1962 command chain No. 1 also began to be intermittent. We would send a command but get no response from the satellite; only after we repeated it a few times would the satellite finally do what it had been told to do. Now there was something to be concerned about. And, if chain No. 1 should fail, we had to make sure that Telstar would be left in a favorable operating condition. We didn’t want the satellite’s communications equipment to be left on without our being able to turn it off—this would keep a continuous drain on the power supply.

As we feared it would, the other command circuit went out of commission on November 23rd. However, when this happened, the communications circuits had been turned off, although the command chains themselves and the telemetry remained on. This meant that we could still try to send commands, the condition of the satellite could still be monitored by telemetry, and the solar cells could still supply useful power. But, since we could not turn the communications equipment on, Telstar I could no longer be used for transatlantic television or any of the experiments we had been carrying on successfully since July.

Looking for the Trouble Spot

At this point a number of Bell Telephone Laboratories engineers began to analyze Telstar’s troubles. As you can imagine, we had a rather difficult problem. We obviously could neither go up and look at Telstar nor bring it down for an overhaul on the ground. We could only send different commands to the satellite and watch the telemetry data to see what, if anything, happened.

After checking the satellite’s other equipment, we were happy to find that everything except the command chains was in good condition. So we decided the trouble had to be one of five possibilities: