[Enthusiastic cheering.

Second Mem. Then it is you who are infamous!

[Uproar.

The Speaker. Gentlemen, Ministers, do not force me to put on my hat—do not cause me to suspend the sitting.

First Mem. Surely a civil question deserves a civil answer?

Esquire Harcourt. Not in a nation that has bled on the field of battle.

[Roars of applause.

First Mem. (after a pause). And yet what I required to know was reasonable. I wished to know whether Esquire Harcourt proposed to name a popular Budget?

Esquire Harcourt. He repeats the calumny!

[Uproar.