"Keeps up the character established by the first number."—Vox Populi (Lowell).
"Should be in the hands of all who desire to know the Bay State."—Westborough Chronotype.
"Of special interest to the citizens of Massachusetts."—Worcester Spy.
"A distinctive Massachusetts magazine."—Waltham Record.
"Both in appearance and contents creditable to the publishers."—New York Literary Times.
"Does credit to publishers and contributors."—East Boston Argus.
"The list of contributors is enough to sell the magazine."—Scituate Herald.
"Is destined to be popular and a valuable addition to the literary world."—Home Journal.
"Rich in contents."—Indianapolis Times.
"A worthy representative of the literary and typographical excellence of cultured Boston."—Weekly Advocate.