Ath p415 My 30 ’19 120w + Boston Transcript p8 Je 5 ’20 550w
Reviewed by Preserved Smith
Nation 110:555 Ap 24 ’20 500w
“It is a dull thing that he has given us, but not without its value. The chief fault of his work is his obvious inability to think himself back into an environment and a mode of life quite different from that of the year 1920.” H. L. Stewart
+ − Review 2:284 Mr 20 ’20 320w
“Every student of the history of Ulster must obtain this most valuable handbook. The publishers have, however, been so remiss as to send it out without either an index or even a table of contents.”
+ − Sat R 127:634 Je 28 ’19 420w
“Lord Ernest Hamilton’s handling of the subject is throughout wonderfully impartial; there are one or two generalizations which betray the side to which his feelings incline him, but he allows no personal prepossessions to interfere with an unbiassed presentation of the facts. The defects of his book are only incidental.”
+ − Spec 122:700 My 31 ’19 1700w + Springf’d Republican p10 Je 22 ’20 260w
“The atmosphere of war-time journalism has penetrated Lord Ernest’s historical study, and even his phraseology has occasionally suffered.”