+ Grinnell R 16:309 D ’20 260w

“Few white Americans but will be astonished, perhaps, at the volume and the eloquence of that voice as here reported with praiseworthy fairness; still fewer, doubtless, but will wonder at the shrewdness with which these negro editors survey the problems of their race.”

+ Nation 111:736 D 22 ’20 120w

“The book should be read by every one interested in the welfare of the country and in the cause of justice.” Clement Wood

+ N Y Call p7 Ja 9 ’21 170w

“Whoever thinks that the negro is not foully abused will find Professor Kerlin’s book wholesome, though unpleasant, reading.”

+ No Am 212:575 O ’20 300w

“A valuable volume for the study of the negro question in America. Typographically the book is not attractive.”

+ Outlook 126:690 D 15 ’20 100w

“A most interesting and worth-while volume.”