Booklist 17:151 Ja ’21 + Bookm 52:367 Ja ’21 120w

“For each matter which Mr Shackleton has not set down, there are a dozen that he has. Mr Shackleton is always interesting.” G. M. H.

+ Boston Transcript p2 N 24 ’20 600w + Outlook 126:690 D 15 ’20 70w

“A truly interesting and broadly conceived tribute to the much abused ‘Windy city.’”

+ R of Rs 63:112 Ja ’21 100w

“The book is far from being a catalogue of land-marks and monuments, or even of merits and faults. It gives to the city a personal quality, and to the reader a sense that here is a mass of people, living, breathing, and enjoying life.”

+ Springf’d Republican p6 D 20 ’20 250w

SHAFER, DONALD CAMERON. Barent Creighton. *$2 (2c) Knopf

20–11224