+ Nation 111:18 Jl 3 ’20 70w
“His interpretation of this history shows keen insight into the play of economic forces that have made for the development of classes, the rise of the labor movement and the evolution of industrial society. On the interpretive side we think that it is more informative than the more laborious work of Professor Commons and associates.” James Oneal
+ N Y Call p10 Je 13 ’20 820w R of Rs 61:671 Je ’20 40w
“I do not see why a book designed to give understanding of the present should deal with Shay’s rebellion and fail to do more than mention either the interesting development among the garment workers of the equally significant changes in the organizations of railroad workers. I have no desire to quarrel with Professor Carlton’s selection, for his temper is tolerant and his mood understanding, qualities to be prized highly among men whose minds are directed to the description of events in the field of labor.”
+ − Survey 41:315 My 29 ’20 100w
“Will serve as a useful introduction to a close study of modern American labour problems.”
+ The Times [London] Lit Sup p425 Jl 1 ’20 30w
“It is only the second half that deals with controversial matters. Here also Professor Carlton’s work is effective in that he carries the reader into the heart of the subject by bringing up all the live and crucial issues. But his frank policy of taking a decided stand upon most of them himself makes it highly desirable that his standpoint should be grasped by the reader, in advance if practicable.” W: E. Walling
+ Yale R n s 10:214 O ’20 900w
CARNEGIE, ANDREW. Autobiography. il *$5 (4c) Houghton