+ + N. Y. Times. 11: 125. Mr. 3, ’06. 1140w. (Review of v. 1 and 2.) N. Y. Times. 11: 415. Je. 23, ’06. 140w. (Review of v. 5–6.)
Lincoln, Charles Z. Constitutional history of New York from the beginning of the colonial period to the year 1905, showing the origin, development, and judicial construction of the constitution. 5v. $15. Lawyers’ co-op.
“We can best give an idea of what the book is by saying that it is arranged both historically and by topics. As a whole, it is the history of the constitution of New York traced from its earliest sources in Magna charta and the ‘Charter of liberties’ down to its present form, accompanied by explanations of the political and social changes underlying its development. But, being arranged also by subjects and having a whole volume of tables and indices, it is easy to find either the chronology and rationale of any particular topic ... or what is often of quite as much importance, the part played in the development of the Constitution by any particular person.”—Nation.
“Not only a monument of industry and research, but a useful historical and legal compilation as well. The author is well qualified for his task.”
+ Nation. 83: 129. Ag. 9, ’06. 570w.
“No effort is made to attract ‘the mind that requires to be tempted to the study of truth.’ The work is not cast in literary form. It can not be read through. The highest praise that can be given to it, the criticism that would gratify the author most highly, is to say that no one seeking any information about the Constitutions of the state of New York is likely to consult these volumes in vain.” Robert Livingston Schuyler.
+ N. Y. Times. 11: 562. S. 15, ’06. 1890w.
Lincoln, Mrs. Jeanie Lincoln Gould. Javelin of fate. †$1.25. Houghton.
A love story of Civil war times with the “main action centering in that hot-bed of rebellion, Baltimore.... For years she escapes the Nemesis of fate, but throughout her brilliant career there is one motive behind her social activities and political intrigues—the wish to punish the man who spoiled her youth and robbed her of the capacity for happiness. At last her opportunity arrives, but old instincts and old affections assert themselves. She forgives the man and goes to find her child. Then the javelin strikes her. This is the main thread of the narrative, which is skilfully interwoven with others less sombre.” (Dial.) “It is only a very distant echo of the war that sounds in Mrs. Lincoln’s story. It is mostly the women’s side of the fray.” (N. Y. Times.)