“Professor Mahaffy is not only a competent scholar, but he is also an interesting writer.”
+ + Outlook. 83: 530. Je. 30, ’06. 190w.
“When he gets fairly to work we find, in this as in all his other writings, that his light handling of his subject is the result of—we will not say laborious, but intelligent and sympathetic study. He has read the authorities whom he cites so profusely, and knows about them whatever may be ascertained from the sources of common information, and this dry material has been fused and quickened by the critic’s appreciation of the author’s genius and character. He breathes life and individuality into figures and names.”
+ + – Sat. R. 102: 618. N. 17, ’06. 1490w.
Mahan, Alfred Thayer. [Sea power in its relations to the war of 1812.] 2v. **$7. Little.
+ + Acad. 69: 1352. D. 30, ’05. 1330w.
“Captain Mahan’s treatment of the war is at once impartial and instructive. The volumes close with the best account of the negotiations which terminated in the treaty of Ghent which has thus far been published.” Gaillard Hunt.
+ + Am. Hist. R. 11: 924. Jl. ’06. 950w.
“We may safely assert that Captain Mahan’s verdict will here be accepted as final.”
+ + Ath. 1906, 1: 290. Mr. 10. 3440w.