+ + – Lond. Times. 5: 80. Mr. 9, ’06. 1250w.
“The very quality that gave Mr. Mathieson’s first work its distinctive excellence is once more apparent in his account of Scottish life during the era of the Union. We refer here to the note of moderation—and of moderation exercised under rather trying circumstances. Mr. Mathieson shows marked skill in blending a portrayal of character with the discussion of purely political issues.”
+ + Nation. 83: 245. S. 20, ’06. 1650w.
“If Burton’s history had not been written, Mr. Mathieson’s would have been of considerable value but we greatly prefer the older work, and we feel strongly that it should have been conspicuously mentioned.”
+ – Sat. R. 101: 368. Mr. 24, ’06. 1060w.
Matthews, (James) Brander (Arthur Penn, pseud.). American character. **75c. Crowell.
In answer to a French criticism that the Americans loved money only, ignored the arts, and despised disinterested beauty, Professor Matthews has written this just estimate of our character as a nation, and has given an analysis of our national traits and trend, which is so unprejudiced that it will claim thoughtful consideration. The address was first delivered before Columbia and Rutgers colleges in 1905.
“One may not agree with Professor Matthews at all times; but for the most part the views expressed are not only well-considered but we think they are sound.”
+ + – Arena. 36: 570. N. ’06. 300w.