“Brilliant though it is, needs to be corrected and restrained in its most important positions before it can be taken as a scientifically reliable narrative of the origins of the Christian faith.”
+ – Cath. World. 83: 554. Jl. ’06. 680w.
“The work is condensed and devoid of technicalities, and has been rendered into excellent English.” T. D. A. Cockerell.
+ + Dial. 40: 323. My. 16, ’06. 980w. Ind. 61: 1165. N. 15, ’06. 50w.
“The work of this great scholar will be widely accepted as conclusive. It presents a serious challenge to the Church. To answer it effectively will require, besides equal genius, preparedness to make some concessions.”
+ Outlook. 82: 856. Ap. 14, ’06. 380w.
Phelps, Albert. Louisiana; a record of expansion. *$1.10. Houghton.
“The book as a whole, shows careful study of the sources, and its accuracy is commendable. There are, however, some errors, due partly to a failure to examine recently discovered documents and partly to other causes.” John R. Ficklen.
+ + – Am. Hist. R. 11: 408. Ja. ’06. 980w.
“The volume is among the most scholarly of the extensive literature called forth by the recent centennial anniversary of the acquisition of this vast territory.”