– – Acad. 69: 1221. N. 25, ’05. 720w.
“Dr. Reich is quite ignorant of his subject, he is unacquainted with the objects, methods, and views of higher criticism, and admittedly considers it unnecessary to treat the study seriously.”
– – Lond. Times. 4: 403. N. 24, ’05. 1500w. R. of Rs. 33: 509. Ap. ’06. 180w. + – – Sat. R. 101: 86. Ja. 20, ’06. 300w.
“We cannot congratulate the anti-critics on their new ally.”
+ – Spec. 93: 62. Ja. 12, ’06. 1260w.
Reid, G. Archdall. Principles of heredity, with some applications. *$3.50. Dutton.
“Although addressed largely to medical men this volume will be found of great value to all students of human progress and social problems. The work begins therefore with a clear statement of the various theories of heredity and evolution. The reviewer knows of no book in which the significance of these differences is more plainly shown. The reviewer has seldom seen a more carefully worked out thesis.” Carl Kelsey.
+ + + Ann. Am. Acad. 27: 254. Ja. ’06. 640w.
“Of the three general characters which distinguish Mr. Reid’s book, this ‘real lucidity’ ... is the first and the most valuable. The second general feature of this volume is what the sportsman would call its keenness. The third feature ... is the mere fact that it is written by a medical man.” C. W. Saleeby.
+ + – Fortnightly R. 84: 604. O. ’05. 5430w.