“He has made an excellent portrait of the great soldier, giving the shadows as well as the lights.”
+ Dial. 40: 239. Ap. 1, ’06. 190w.
“His is distinctly not a biography, but a military memoir.”
+ – Lit. D. 32: 332. Mr. 3, ’06. 510w.
“There is a pleasant atmosphere of fairness about his book.”
+ N. Y. Times. 11: 50. Ja. 27, ’06. 520w.
“It presents a truthful and striking portrait, and is very acceptable as a military memoir. It is to be wished that in his presentation he had attained a higher level of literary quality.”
+ – Outlook. 82: 327. F. 10, ’06. 170w.
“The book is written attractively and with due regard to the official and standard authorities.”
+ R. of Rs. 33: 253. F. ’06. 120w.