“Herbert Strang may be congratulated on another first-rate book.”

+ Ath. 1905, 2: 720. N. 25. 100w. + Critic. 48: 574. Je. ’06. 80w.

“The fault of the story is that it is too long, and, to tell the truth, is sometimes tedious. Yet there is more good matter in it than in most of the kind.”

+ – Lond. Times. 4: 385. N. 10, ’05. 150w.

“A good story for boys.”

+ N. Y. Times. 11: 197. Mr. 31, ’06. 510w.

“An admirable piece of work.”

+ Outlook. 82: 761. Mr. 31, ’06. 110w.

“Is certainly a success.”