“One cannot regard Mr. Chesterton as the ideal critic of Charles Dickens though he makes a very effective apologist.”
+ – Sat. R. 102: 368. S. 22, ’06. 1510w.
“The book, taken as a whole, is as warm and understanding a tribute as any hand has laid on the great writer’s grave. We find ourselves also largely in accordance with him when he blames and demurs.”
+ + – Spec. 97: 364. S. 15, ’06. 2500w.
Chesterton, Gilbert Keith. [Club of queer trades.] †$1.25. Harper.
“They have not a free inventive stroke. They are whimsical and studied.”
+ – Reader. 6: 727. N. ’05. 160w.
Chesterton, Gilbert Keith. [Heretics.] *$1.50. Lane.
“As a critic, not only of heretics but of various aspects and relations of life discussed in this volume, when he has finished off the heretics, Mr. Chesterton shows a definite advance in clearness and force.”
+ Nation. 82: 208. Mr. 8, ’06. 1500w.