“The book is strongest on the side of opinion, theology, and controversial literature.” William Elliot Griffis.
+ Am. Hist. R. 11: 654. Ap. ’06. 860w.
“A very minute and learned study of the early founders of Congregationalism.”
+ + – Ath. 1906, 2: 126. Ag. 4. 280w.
“This work is absolutely unique in thoroness and accuracy.”
+ + + Ind. 60: 455. F. 22, ’06. 270w.
“Lightness of touch this volume does not possess in an eminent degree, but it contains a large amount of information which has been digested with affectionate and conscientious care.”
+ + Nation. 82: 372. My. 3, ’06. 810w.
“This is by all odds the most complete record of Pilgrim origins yet published in this country.”
+ + + R. of Rs. 33: 115. Ja. ’06. 150w.