“His characters look like posters and talk like Mr. Huneker. Nobody will deny that the result is interesting, but it is not fiction of the first order.”
+ – Critic. 48: 381. Ap. ’06. 220w.
“It seems a pity that any one who can upon occasion write so well should so often let his imagination ride him into the country of the grotesque.”
+ – Lond. Times. 5: 30. Ja. 26, ’06. 620w.
“They are odd in conception and admirably told.”
+ Outlook. 81: 684. N. 18, ’05. 40w.
“Most of them are fantastic, some of them are decadent, all of them are intensely modern in method. But what he does he does with subtle and finished skill, and the product is interesting reading.”
+ + Pub. Opin. 39: 859. D. 30, ’05. 90w.
“There have always been touches in Mr. Huneker’s work that suggest his possession of positive genius. But ‘Visionaries’ outsteps all bounds of reason, is almost wholly fantastic, esoteric, narcotic.”
+ – Reader. 7: 226. Ja. ’06. 350w.