+ Acad. 70: 223. Mr. 10, ’06. 1780w.
“We have already hinted that Miss Roscoe’s editorial work has been well done; but these essays should not have been issued without an index, and one regrets that undue reverence for her author has restrained her from occasionally emending his text.”
+ – Ath. 1906, 1: 416. Ap. 7. 530w.
“These additional gleanings from the late R. H. Hutton’s contributions to the ‘Spectator’ are excellent specimens of the reviewer’s art, with the exception of a few slight crudities of style and thought inseparable from the nature of such work.”
+ – Ind. 61: 222. Jl. 26, ’06. 280w. Lit. D. 32: 565. Ap. 14, ’06. 1120w. + Nation. 83: 249. S. 20, ’06. 330w.
“One cannot say that the volume contains anything like a body of critical doctrine. But one can say that it contains a great deal of stimulating and suggestive discourse.” Montgomery Schuyler.
+ N. Y. Times. 11: 220. Ap. 7, ’06. 1010w.
“This selection covers a wide range, and brings out the diversity of Mr. Hutton’s gifts, the breadth of his sympathies, and the ease and clearness of his style.”
+ Outlook. 82: 907. Ap. 21, ’06. 160w.
“Carefully chosen and edited.”