“We welcome another powerful counterblast from the graceful and vigorous pen of Mr. Andrew Lang against the disintegrators of the poems of Homer.” R. Y. Tyrrell.
| + | Acad. 71: 543. D. 1, ’06. 1600w. |
“It is a fascinating book, and a noteworthy. Mr. Lang was born too late to keep the wolf from the door of the Homeric house, but this championship of Homer will go far to bring the poet’s scattered goods together again under one roof, to be the heirlooms of Achaean glory.”
| + + | Acad. 72: 624. Je. 29, ’07. 2200w. |
“Altogether, from frontispiece ... to finis, the book is one for which every Homeric student may well be grateful.” J. Irving Manatt.
| + + | Am. Hist. R. 12: 605. Ap. ’07. 700w. |
“We are sorry that Mr. Lang has not treated his subject more thoroughly, because we are at one with him in most that he says, and would fain go the whole way if we could.”
| + − | Ath. 1907. 1: 38. Ja. 12. 1260w. |
“Mr. Lang’s polemic, despite much repetition and some wearisome details, holds the attention by a wealth of pertinent illustration from Norse and Old French literature, and by the force and cunning of his dialectical swordplay.” Paul Shorey.
| + − | Dial. 42: 248. Ap. 16, ’07. 1450w. |