| + + | Dial. 43: 118. S. 1, ’07. 670w. |
“He has much to say, but somehow has not succeeded in saying it effectively. The watercolour drawings of Mr. Martin show in a noticeable degree the defects of his literary collaborator.”
| + − | Int. Studio. 32: 335. O. ’07. 280w. |
“In selecting Dr. Wilfred Campbell, the well-known Canadian poet, to write the descriptive matter for this book, the publishers made on the whole a commendable choice.”
| + + − | Nation. 85: 148. Ag. 15, 510w. |
“The ‘description’ let it be said at once, is rather dull reading, in a style which suggests not so much the guide book as the promoter’s prospectus, with a dash of that sort of sentiment which is the stock in trade of the patriotic campaign orator. These pictures are, on the whole, rather good than bad though, like most pictures of the sort, they make the colors too bright.”
| + − | N. Y. Times. 12: 482. Ag. 3, ’07. 470w. |
“Author and painter have combined happily and successfully in presenting Canadian life and scenery agreeably and with abundant and dependable information.”
| + | Outlook. 86: 525. Jl. 6, ’07. 130w. |
“On the whole his commentary makes pleasant if not often impressive reading.”