| + | N. Y. Times. 11: 912. D. 29, ’06. 140w. |
Grove, Sir George, ed. Dictionary of music and musicians; new and thoroughly rev. ed.; ed. by J. A. Fuller Maitland. **$5. Macmillan.
v. 3. “The new volume 3, which begins with Maas and ends with Pyne, includes for the first time, the names of MacDowell, Mahler, Mancinelli, Mascagni, Milloeker, Napravnik, Paderewski, Paine, Parker, Pierne, and Puccini among the composers; while to the list of singers and conductors have been added the names of Mallinger, Malten, Maurel, Mottl, Nevada, Nikisch, Nordica.”—Nation.
| + − | Ath. 1907. 1: 419. Ap. 6. 1290w. (Review of v. 3.) |
“Fully sustains the reputation of its two predecessors for accuracy of historical statement, comprehensiveness of scope, and conservatism of criticism.”
| + + + | Dial. 42: 256. Ap. 17, ’07. 600w. (Review of v. 3.) | |
| + + | Ind. 63: 342. Ag. 8, ’07. 340w. (Review of v. 3.) |
“It proves, like the previous two volumes, that the revision is an earnest one, seeking out the omissions and deficiencies of the original, and placing the new tasks in hands almost always the most capable to be found.”
| + − | Lond. Times. 6: 133. Ap. 26, ’07. 2550w. (Review of v. 3.) |
“Altogether, the space has been expanded by over one-fifth, and the editor and his associates have almost invariably done their work well, thus making ‘Grove,’ more than ever, a necessity to every amateur and student.”