| + + | Ann. Am. Acad. 25: 606. My. ‘05. 650w. |
Reviewed by Winthrop More Daniels.
| Atlan. 95: 552. Ap. ‘05. 300w. |
“This study in political pathology will be a welcome addition to the books available to the student of political science. There seems to be nothing omitted from this little hand-book that any student of party methods or management could possibly wish to know.”
| + + + | N. Y. Times. 10: 86. F. 11, ‘05. 660w. |
“Survey is very broad. As a rule, Professor Macy is direct and explicit but he is not always consistent, and we note occasional slips liable to lead to misconstruction of his position. Whatever there is of error, however, is not sufficient to vitiate the value of his work.”
| + — | Outlook. 78: 1043. D. 24, ‘04. 290w. | |
| + + | R. of Rs. 30: 761. D. ‘04. 230w. |
Madison, James. Writings; ed. by Gaillard Hunt. v. 5, 1787-1790. subs. [*]$5. Putnam.
“Mr. Hunt’s third and fourth volumes, consisting chiefly of Madison’s notes of debates in the Federal convention, brought us down to the date of its adjournment in September, 1787. The present volume carries us but two years and a half farther.... Of a hundred and eight letters printed by Mr. Hunt there are only a dozen that have not been printed before.... Six came from the Madison papers, two from the collections of the New York library, two from the Virginia historical society, one from a North Carolina source, and one, a letter of some interest written to Philip Mazzei, was once the property of Guizot and is now in a private collection in Berlin.... Madison’s speeches in the Virginia convention occupy nearly a fourth of the volume. His speeches in the first two sessions of the First congress, running to nearly as great extent, are also given.”—Am. Hist. R.
“Mr. Hunt’s annotations are apposite and intelligent.” J. Franklin Jameson.