— —Dial. 38: 315. My. 1, ‘05. 430w.

“It is only valuable as an effort to substantiate the South’s treatment of the negro. It contains neither scientific accuracy nor literary excellence.”

+ —Ind. 58: 843. Ap. 13, ‘05. 290w.
— +Nation. 81: 280. O. 5, ‘05. 1130w.

“It may be Professor Smith has allowed his predispositions to color his conclusions somewhat.”

+ +N. Y. Times. 10: 82. F. 11, ‘05. 1820w.

“In six passionately written chapters brimming with science and statistics, Professor Smith makes a strong presentation of the position of the South on the negro question.”

+ +Pub. Opin. 38: 297. F. 25, ‘05. 500w.
R. of Rs. 31: 382. Mr. ‘05. 100w.

[*] Smythe, William Eilsworth. Constructive democracy: the economics of a square deal. [**]$1.50. Macmillan.

“This volume presents the evils of the present industrial system and proposes three remedies. The first is Senator Newland’s plan for dealing with the transportation problem.... The second remedy is Mr. Garfield’s plan.... The first remedy would put the railroads, the second the trusts, under the supervision of the National government. The third remedy is National irrigation for the development of our unused lands, and adequate protection of them from the land-grabber, that they may furnish an opportunity for the ‘surplus man.’”—Outlook.

* N. Y. Times. 10: 708. O. 21, ‘05. 280w.