| — — | Acad. 68: 984. S. 23, ‘05. 280w. |
“This story is fundamentally unsound, superficially clever, and for the most part entertaining.”
| + — | Ath. 1905, 2: 298. S. 2. 280w. |
“The story is one of unusual cleverness, and full of surprises to the end.” Frederic Taber Cooper.
| + + | Bookm. 21: 517. Jl. ‘05. 520w. |
“‘Tommy Carteret’ is quite readable, even entertaining, though it is the kind of book some superior persons sneer at and consign to the limbo of nothingness.”
| + | N. Y. Times. 10: 166. Mr. 18, ‘05. 390w. | |
| N. Y. Times. 10: 393. Je. 17, ‘05. 190w. |
“The book is full of sentimental absurdities and affectation, and in the end degenerates into a most unpleasant pseudo-pathological study.”
| — | Outlook. 79: 761. Mr. 25, ‘05. 90w. |
“A book that unites so much power and charm, so much insight and kindliness and truth.”