“These measures of repression strike the innocent and cause terror to reign among the French population . . . .


“A great number of the acts that have been mentioned took place in the course of repressive operations directed against population accused of having relations with the Maquis. In these operations there was never any care taken to discover whether the people suspected of having served the Maquis were really guilty; and still less in this case, to ascertain whether these people had acted voluntarily or under duress. The number of innocent people executed is therefore considerable. . . .


“The repressive operation in Dordogne, from 26 March to 3 April 1944, and particularly the tragic affair of Ascq, which have already brought about the intervention of the head of the French Government, are grievous examples. At Ascq, especially, 86 innocent people paid with their lives for an attempted attack which, according to my information, did not cause the death of a single German soldier. . . .


“Such acts can only stimulate the spirit of revolt in the adversaries of Germany, who finally are the only ones to benefit.”

The reply of the Armistice Commission, Document F-707, submitted as Exhibit Number RF-436, is the rejection of General Bérard’s request. The document is before you. I do not think it is necessary for me to read it.

The general, on 3 August 1944, reiterated his protest. This is Document F-673, Exhibit Number RF-392, already submitted. At the end of his protest he writes: