C. Evidence of Knight and Laxton.
In the last two sections we have seen that in using peas of the “grey” class, i.e. with brown, red, or purplish coats, special phenomena are to be looked for, and also that in the case of large “indented” peas, the phenomena of size and shape may show some divergence from that simple form of the phenomenon of dominance seen when ordinary round and wrinkled are crossed. Here the fuller discussion of these phenomena must have been left to await further experiment, were it not that we have other evidence bearing on the same questions.
The first is that of Knight’s well-known experiments, long familiar but until now hopelessly mysterious. I have not space to quote the various interpretations which Knight and others have put upon them, but as the Mendelian principle at once gives a complete account of the whole, this is scarcely necessary, though the matter is full of historical interest.
Crossing a white pea with a very large grey purple-flowered form Knight (21) found that the peas so produced “were not in any sensible degree different from those afforded by other plants of the same [white] variety; owing, I imagine, to the external covering of the seed (as I have found in other plants) being furnished entirely by the female[99].” All grew very tall[100], and had colours of male parent[101]. The seeds they produced were dark grey[102].
“I had frequent occasion to observe, in this plant [the hybrid], a stronger tendency to produce purple blossoms, and coloured seeds, than white ones; for when I introduced the farina of a purple blossom into a white one, the whole of the seeds in the succeeding year became coloured [viz. DR × D giving DD and DR]; but, when I endeavoured to discharge this colour, by reversing the process, a part only of them afforded plants with white blossoms; this part sometimes occupying one end of the pod, and being at times irregularly intermixed with those which, when sown, retained their colour” [viz. DR × R giving DR and RR] (draws conclusions, now obviously erroneous[103]).
In this account we have nothing not readily intelligible in the light of Mendel’s hypothesis.
The next evidence is supplied by an exceptionally complete record of a most valuable experiment made by Laxton[104]. The whole story is replete with interest, and as it not only carries us on somewhat beyond the point reached by Mendel, but furnishes an excellent illustration of how his principles may be applied, I give the whole account in Laxton’s words, only altering the paragraphing for clearness, and adding a commentary. The paper appears in Jour. Hort. Soc. N.S. III. 1872, p. 10, and very slightly abbreviated in Jour. of Hort. XVIII. 1870, p. 86. Some points in the same article do not specially relate to this section, but for simplicity I treat the whole together. It is not too much to say that two years ago the whole of this story would have been a maze of bewildering confusion. There are still some points in it that we cannot fully comprehend, for the case is one of far more than ordinary complexity, but the general outlines are now clear. In attempting to elucidate the phenomena it will be remembered that there are no statistics (those given being inapplicable), and the several offspring are only imperfectly referred to the several classes of seeds. This being so, our rationale cannot hope to be complete. Laxton states that as the seeds of peas are liable to change colour with keeping, for this and other reasons he sent to the Society a part of the seeds resulting from his experiment before it was brought to a conclusion.
“The seeds exhibited were derived from a single experiment. Amongst these seeds will be observed some of several remarkable colours, including black, violet, purple-streaked and spotted, maple, grey, greenish, white, and almost every intermediate tint, the varied colours being apparently produced on the outer coat or envelope of the cotyledons only.
The peas were selected for their colours, &c., from the third year’s sowing in 1869 of the produce of a cross in 1866 of the early round white-seeded and white-flowered garden variety “Ringleader,” which is about 2 1/2 ft. in height, fertilised by the pollen of the common purple-flowered “maple” pea, which is taller than “Ringleader,” and has slightly indented seeds. I effected impregnation by removing the anthers of the seed-bearer, and applying the pollen at an early stage. This cross produced a pod containing five round white peas, exactly like the ordinary “Ringleader” seeds[105].
In 1867 I sowed these seeds, and all five produced tall purple-flowered purplish-stemmed plants[106], and the seeds, with few exceptions, had all maple or brownish-streaked envelopes of various shades; the remainder had entirely violet or deep purple-coloured envelopes[107]: in shape the peas were partly indented; but a few were round[108]. Some of the plants ripened off earlier than the “maple,” which, in comparison with “Ringleader,” is a late variety; and although the pods were in many instances partially abortive, the produce was very large[109].