5. FALLACIES OF IMMEDIATE INFERENCE.
Fallacies of immediate inference arise from some violation of the rules which this topic enunciates.
(1) Opposition.
Among other statements opposition posits these two: (1) When the particular is true its opposing universal is indeterminate; (2) A universal negative does not necessarily contradict a universal affirmative.
These signify that neither an A nor an E must be assumed to be true when the corresponding I or O is true, and that E may not always contradict A, nor O contradict I.
ILLUSTRATIONS OF FALLACIES OF OPPOSITION.
(1) Since some men are wise, then I may conclude that all men are wise.
(2) I have contradicted his statement “all men are honest” by proving that no men are honest.
There is little difference between fallacies like (1) and fallacies of converse accident. Concerning illustration (2), both statements are false; but to contradict we know that if one is false, the other must be true.
(2) Obversion.
“Two negatives are equivalent to one affirmative,” is the principle underlying obversion. The most common fallacy in obversion springs from using one negative instead of two.
ILLUSTRATIONS OF FALLACIOUS OBVERSION.
(a) Original: Some men are not wise. Obverse: (incorrect) Some men are wise.
(b) Original: All true teachers are just. Obverse: (incorrect) All true teachers are not just.
(3) Conversion.
Conversion involves the interchanging of the subject and predicate of a proposition without affecting the distribution; in consequence the usual fallacy incident to this interchange is distributing an undistributed term.
ILLUSTRATIONS OF FALLACY OF CONVERSION.
(a) Original: All fixed stars are heavenly bodies. Converted: (incorrectly) All heavenly bodies are fixed stars.
(b) Original: Some men are not wise. Converted: (incorrectly) Some wise beings are not men.
(4) Contraversion.
As this process involves the two steps of obversion and conversion, fallacies appertaining to contraversion would relate to these two steps.
ILLUSTRATIONS OF FALLACIES OF CONTRAVERSION.
(a) Original: No honest man fails to pay his debts. Contraverted: (incorrectly) Some who do not pay their debts are honest men.
(b) Original: Some animals are quadrupeds. Contraverted: (incorrectly) Some not-quadrupeds are not animals.
The formal fallacies of categorical, hypothetical, and disjunctive arguments have received detailed treatment inchapters 11, 14 and 15; we may, therefore, devote our attention to the material fallacies without further delay.