In 1884, the following twenty varieties were grown. The seeds were sown in a green-house March 5 and 6, and the plants set out May 2. It appears from the table that some of the varieties called "late," formed heads earlier than others called "early." The Lenormand Extra Large was the earliest, forming its first head in 149 days, the Lackawanna heading a day later. None of the heads were extra large:

VARIETY.First head in days.Plants survived.No. of heads.
Dwarf Erfurt18244
Early Dutch or Early London18054
Early Dwarf Surprise17566
Eclipse16276
Half-Early Large White French19096
Half-Early Paris19787
Imperial16088
Lackawanna15098
Large Algiers18963
Large Late Asiatic15644
Large Late Stadtholder-83
Late Giant Italian15488
Late Paris17043
Lenormand's Extra Large14976
Lenormand's Short-Stemmed16186
Paris Extra Early15466
Sea Foam18232
Veitch's Autumn Giant18263
Very Dwarf Alleaume18986
Walcheren18264

In 1885 the following varieties were planted in the green-house March 30, and sixteen plants of each, with a few exceptions, transplanted to the garden May 4. The plants of Algiers and Le Maitre Pied Court were transplanted May 20, and those of the Wonderful May 21. The plants were set in rows three and one-half feet apart, and eighteen inches apart in the rows. Many were destroyed by various causes, and though the places were twice reset there were many vacancies.

As will be seen, Henderson's Early Snowball (from Henderson in 1885) was the earliest, forming the first head July 8, or ninety-seven days from sowing the seed. The heads also were rather above the average in size. Extra selected Dwarf Erfurt was the second in earliness and every plant headed.

A notable fact brought out by this table is the effect of the early planting on the late and half-early varieties. It might be supposed, as these varieties require a long season, that this early planting would give the best results, enabling them to attain their full development. But it appears that it caused many of the plants to head prematurely when small, while it greatly prolonged the season of the variety.

VARIETY.First head.No. of plants.No. of heads.Average diameter of head.
AlgiersAug. 1422197½
AlleaumeSept. 24 5 47
Autumn GiantSept. 2417177
D'AlgerSept. 1514127½
Demi dur de St. BrieucSept. 1511117
Early Dutch (dur d'Holland)Aug. 2512 85
Early Dwarf Erfurt (Thorburn)July 1311117½
Early Dwarf Erfurt (Vilmorin)July 13 5 45½
Early LondonAug. 2516127½
Early ParisJuly 2511 65½
Early PicpusAug. 512108
Early SnowballJuly 3117157
Extra E. Dw'f Erfurt (Hend'son)Sept. 2718 86
Extra E'ly Dw'f Erfurt (Thorb'n)July 1312115½
Extra Earliest Paris (Vilmorin)Aug. 10 7 67½
Extra Early ParisJuly 2513 67½
Extra Selected E'ly Dwarf ErfurtJuly 2113135
Half Early Dwarf FrenchJuly 2512 77½
Half Early Paris (Thorburn)Aug. 2412116½
Half Early Paris (Vilmorin)Sept. 1511117
Henderson's Early SnowballJuly 812 97½
ImperialAug. 1010 86½
Landreth's FirstJuly 13 6 55½
Large Early LondonOct. 2714 46
Large Late AsiaticAug. 2511 78
Late Giant NaplesOct. 17 5 34
Late ParisAug. 1210 77½
Late StadtholderOct. 711 65½
Le Maitre Pied CourtAug. 1415137
LenormandSept. 1512106½
Len'm'd Short-stem'd (Hend'son)Aug. 1420116
Len'm'd Short-stem'd (Vilmorin)July 2512 77
Purple Cape (Noir de Sicilie)Aug. 1012 86½
Thorburn's NonpareilAug. 1412 86½
Veitch's Autumn GiantSept. 2413117½
Walcheren (Henderson)Sept. 1 4 47½
Walcheren (Vilmorin)Aug. 5 6 67
WonderfulOct. 27 7 66

The following early varieties were tested in 1888. The seeds were all sown May 10, and the plants set out June 23, two by three and one-half feet. All the varieties headed well, except one called "Early," from the English Specialty and Novelty Seed Co., which formed no heads.

Variety.Seeds from.No. of plants.No. of heads.Fit for table use.
Dreer's E'st SnowstormDreer.11 8Sept. 24
Earliest Dwarf ErfurtVaughn. 9 5Sept. 6
Extra E. Dwarf ErfurtTillinghast. 9 4Sept. 29
Gilt-edge SnowballThorburn.1210Aug. 25
Henderson's E. Snowb'lHenderson.12 8Sept. 6
Long Island BeautyTillinghast.11 8Sept. 14
Long Island BeautyBragg.1211Aug. 25
New Early PadillaTillinghast.11 8Aug. 29

At the same station, in 1889, the following varieties were tested. The seed was sown in frames April 23, and the plants set out June 22. The Early Erfurt and Early Snowball were from seed grown by H. A. March, of Fidalgo, Washington.

Variety.Seeds from.No. of plants.Fit for table use.Number of heads.Average diameter.
Inches
Early PuritanFerry.20Aug. 21135½
Early ErfurtMarch.20Aug. 22198½
SnowballMarch.20Aug. 24207½
Vick's IdealVick.20Aug. 30207