The “proper margin” reaches its highest development in the lecideine and graphideine types. It is less prominent or often almost entirely replaced when the thalline margin is superadded, except in genera such as Thelotrema and Diploschistes which have distinct “double margins.”
There is an unusual type of apothecium in the genus Gyrophora. The fruit is lecideine, the thalline gonidia taking no part in the development. The growth of the initial ascogenous tissue, according to Lindau[659], is constantly towards the periphery of the disc so that a weak spot arises in the centre which is promptly filled by a vigorous sterile growth of paraphyses. This process is repeated from new centres again and again, resulting in the irregularly concentric lines of sterile and fertile areas of the “gyrose” fruit ([Fig. 103]). The paraphyses soon become black at the tips. Asci are not formed until the ascogenous layer has acquired a certain degree of stability, and spores are accordingly present only in advanced stages of growth.
Fig. 103. Apothecial gyrose discs of Gyrophora cylindrica Ach. × 12 (after Lindau).
G. Lichen Asci and Spores
a. Historical. The presence of spores, as such, in the lichen fruit was first established by Hedwig[660] in Anaptychia (Physcia) ciliaris. He rightly judged the minute bodies to be the “semina” of the plant. In that species they are fairly large, measuring about 50µ, long and 24µ thick, and as they are very dark in colour when mature, they stand out conspicuously from the surrounding colourless tissue of the hymenium. Acharius[661] also took note of these “semina” and happily replaced the term by that of “spores.” They may be produced, he states, in a compact nucleus (Sphaerophoron), in a naked disc (Calicium), or they may be embedded in the disc (Opegrapha and Lecidea). Sprengel[662] opined that the spores—which he figures—were true seeds, though he allows that there had been no record of their development into new plants. Luyken[663] made a further contribution to the subject by dividing lichens into gymnocarpous and angiocarpous forms, according as the spores, enclosed in cells or vesicles (thecae), were borne in an open disc or in a closed perithecium.
In his Systema of lichen genera Eschweiler[664], some years later, described and figured the spores as “thecae” enclosed in cylindrical asci. Fée[665] in contemporary works gave special prominence to the colour and form of the spores in all the lichens dealt with.
b. Development of the Ascus. The first attempt to trace the origin and development of lichen asci and spores was made by Mohl[666]. He describes the mother-cell (the ascus) as filled at first with a clouded granular substance changing later into a definite number—usually eight—of simple or septate spores. Dangeard[667] included the lichens Borrera (Physcia) ciliaris and Endocarpon (Dermatocarpon) miniatam among the plants that he studied for ascus and spore development. He found that in lichens, as in fungi, the ascus arose usually from the penultimate cell of a crooked hypha ([Fig. 104]) and that it contained at first two nuclei derived from adjoining cells. These nuclei are similar in size to those of the vegetative hyphae, and in each there is a large nucleolus with chromatin material massed on one side. Fusion takes place, as in fungi, between the two nuclei, and the secondary or definitive nucleus thus formed divides successively to form the eight spore-nuclei. Baur[668] and Nienburg[669] have confirmed Dangeard’s results as regards lichens, and René Maire[670] has also contributed important cytological details on the development of the spores. In Anaptychia (Physcia) ciliaris he found that the fused nucleus became larger and that a synapsis stage supervened during which the long slender chromatin filaments became paired, and at the same time shorter and thicker. The nuclear membrane disappeared as the chromatin filaments were united in masses joined together by linin threads which also disappeared later. At the most advanced stage observed by Maire there was visible a nucleolus embedded in a condensed plasma and surrounded by eight medianly constricted filaments destined to form the equatorial plate. A few isolated observations were also made on the cytology of the ascus in Peltigera canina, in which lichen the preceding ascogonial development is wholly vegetative. The secondary nucleus was seen to contain a chromatin mass and a large nucleolus; in addition two angular bodies of uncertain signification were associated with the nucleolus, each with a central vacuole. The nucleolus disappeared in the prophase of the first division and four double chromosomes were then plainly visible. The succeeding phases of the first and the second nuclear division were not seen, but in the prophase of the third it was possible to distinguish four chromatin masses outside the nucleolus. The slow growth of the lichen plant renders continuous observation extremely difficult.