In a recent study of a crustaceous sandstone lichen, “Caloplaca pyracea,” Claassen[217] has sought to prove a case of pure parasitism. The rock was at first covered with the green cells of Cystococcus sp. Later there appeared greyish-white patches on the green, representing the invasion of the lichen fungus. These patches increased centrifugally, leaving in time a bare patch in the centre of growth which was again colonized by the green alga. The lichen fruited abundantly, but wherever it encroached the green cells were more or less destroyed. The true explanation seems to be that the green cells were absorbed into the lichen thallus, though enough of them persisted to start new colonies on any bare piece of the stone. In the same way large patches of Trentepohlia aurea have been observed to be gradually invaded by the dark coloured hyphae of Coenogonium ebeneum. In time the whole of the alga is absorbed and nothing is to be seen but the dark felted lichen. The free alga as such disappears, but it is hardly correct to describe the process as one of destruction.
This algal genus Trentepohlia (Chroolepus) forms the gonidia of the Graphideae, Roccelleae, etc. It is a filamentous aerial alga which increases by apical growth. In the Graphideae, many of which grow on trees beneath the outer bark (hypophloeodal), the association between the two symbionts may be of the simplest character, but was considered by Frank[218] to be of an advanced type. According to his observations and to those of Lindau[219], the fungal hyphae penetrate first between the cells of the periderm. The alga, frequently Trentepohlia umbrina, tends to grow down into any cracks of the surface. It goes more deeply in when preceded by the hyphae. In some species both organisms maintain their independent growth, though each shows increased vigour when it comes into contact with the other. In some instances the cells of the alga are clasped by the fungus which causes the disintegration of the filament. The cells lose their bright yellow or reddish colour and are changed in appearance to greenish lichen gonidia; but no penetration by haustoria has ever been observed in Trentepohlia.
Bachmann’s[220] study of a similar gonidium in a calcicolous species of Opegrapha confirms Frank’s results. The algae had pierced not only between the looser lime granules but also through a crystal of calcium carbonate, and occupied nests scooped out in the rock by means of acid formed and excreted by their filaments. When association took place with the fungus, the algal cells were more restricted to a gonidial zone; but some of the cells, having been pushed aside by the hyphae, had started new centres of gonidia. On contact with the hyphae there was a tendency to bud out in a yeast-like growth.
In the thallus of the Roccelleae, the algal filament, also a Trentepohlia, is broken up into separate cells, but in the Coenogoniaceae, whether the gonidium be a Cladophora as in Racodium, or a Trentepohlia as in Coenogonium, the filaments remain intact and are invested more or less closely by the hyphae.
Fig. 13. Outer edge of Phycopeltis expansa Jenn., the alga attacked by hyphae and passing into separate gonidia × 500 (after Vaughan Jennings).
A somewhat different type of association takes place between alga and fungus in Strigula complanata, an epiphyllous lichen more or less common in tropical regions. Cunningham[221], who found it near Calcutta, described the algal constituent and placed it in a new genus, Mycoidea (Cephaleuros). It forms small plate-like expansions on the surface of the leaf, and also penetrates below the cuticle, burrowing between that and the epidermal cells; occasionally, as observed by Cunningham, rhizoid-like growths pierce deeper into the tissue—into and below the epidermal layer. Very frequently, in the wet season, a fungus takes possession of the alga and slender colourless hyphae creep along its surface by the side of the cell rows, sending out branches which grow downwards. Marshall Ward[222] described the same lichen from Ceylon. He states that the alga may be attacked at any stage, and if it is in a very young condition it is killed by the fungus; at a more advanced period of growth it continues to develop as an integral part of the lichen thallus, but with more frequently divided and smaller cells. Vaughan Jennings[223] observed Strigula complanata in New Zealand associated with a closely allied chroolepoid alga Phycopeltis expansa. He also noted the growth of the fungus over the alga breaking up the plates of tissue and separating the cells which, from yellow, change to a green colour and become rounded off ([Fig. 13]). The mature lichen, a white thallus dotted with black fruits, contrasts strikingly with the yellow membranous alga. Lichen formation usually begins near the edge of the leaf and the margin of the thallus itself is marked by a green zone showing where the fungus has recently come into contact with the alga.
More recently Hans Fitting[224] has described “Mycoidea parasitica” as it occurs on evergreen leaves in Java. The alga, a species of Cephaleuros, though at first an epiphyte, becomes partially parasitic at maturity. It penetrates below the cuticle to the outer epidermal cells and may even reach the tissue below. When it is joined by the lichen fungus, both constituents grow together to form the lichen. Fitting adds that the leaf is evidently but little injured. In this lichen the alga in the grip of the fungus loses its independence and may be killed off: it is an instance of something like intermittent parasitism.
J. Recent views on Symbiosis and Parasitism
No hyphal penetration of the bright-green algal cell by means of haustoria had been observed by the earlier workers, Bornet[225], Bonnier[226] and others, though they followed Schwendener[227] in regarding the relationship as one of host and parasite. Lindau, also, after long study accepted parasitism as the only adequate explanation of the associated growth, though he never found the fungus actually preying on the alga.