Newton’s objection to the wave theory was not answered very convincingly by Huyghens. Today we know that light waves of high frequency tend to travel in straight lines, but may be prevented from doing so by gravitational forces of bodies near its path. But this is Einstein’s discovery.
A very famous experiment by Foucault in 1853 proved beyond the shadow of a doubt that Newton’s corpuscular theory was untenable. According to Newton’s theory, the velocity of light must be greater in a denser medium (such as water) than in a lighter one (such as air). According to the wave theory the reverse is true. Foucault showed that light does travel more slowly in water than in air. The facts were against Newton and in favor of Huyghens; and where facts and theory clash there is but one thing to do: discard the theory.
Some Facts about Newton. Newton was a Cambridge man, and Newton made Cambridge famous as a mathematical center. Since Newton’s day Cambridge has boasted of a Clerk Maxwell and a Rayleigh, and her Larmor, her J. J. Thomson and her Rutherford are still with us. Newton entered Trinity College when he was 18 and soon threw himself into higher mathematics. In 1669, when but 27 years old, he became professor of mathematics at Cambridge, and later represented that seat of learning in Parliament. When his friend Montague became Chancellor of the Exchequer, Newton was offered, and accepted, the lucrative position of Master of the Mint. As president of the Royal Society Newton was occasionally brought in contact with Queen Anne. She held Newton in high esteem, and in 1705 she conferred the honor of knighthood on him. He died in 1727.
“I do not know,” wrote Newton, “what I may appear to the world, but, to myself, I seem to have been only like a boy playing on the seashore, and directing myself in now and then finding a smoother pebble or a prettier shell than ordinary, whilst the great ocean of truth lay all undiscovered before me.”
Such was the modesty of one whom many regard as the greatest intellect of all ages.
References
An excellent account of Newton may be found in Sir R. S. Ball’s Great Astronomers (Sir Isaac Pitman and Sons, Ltd., London). Sedgewick and Tyler’s A Short History of Science (Macmillan, 1918) and Cajori’s A History of Mathematics (Macmillan, 1917) may also be consulted to advantage. The standard biography is that by Brewster.