The hesitation to present the Amendment is increased, when we consider the difficulties in the way of its ratification. I am no arithmetician, but I understand that nobody has yet been able to enumerate the States whose votes can be counted on to assure its ratification within any reasonable time. Meanwhile this great question, which cannot brook delay, which for the sake of peace and to complete Reconstruction should be settled at once, is handed over to prolonged controversy in the States. I need not depict the evils which must ensue. A State will become for the time a political caldron, into which will be dropped all the poisoned ingredients of prejudice and hate, while a powerful political party, chanting, like the Witches in “Macbeth,”
“Double, double, toil and trouble;
Fire, burn; and, caldron, bubble,”
will use this very Amendment as the pudding-stick with which to stir the bubbling mass. Such a controversy should be avoided, if possible; nor should an agitation so unwelcome and so sterile be needlessly invited. “Let us have peace.”
Of course, if there were no other way of accomplishing the great result, the Amendment should be presented, even with all its delays, uncertainties, and provocations to local strife. But happily all these are unnecessary. The same thing may be accomplished by Act of Congress, without any delay, without any uncertainty, and without any provocation to local strife. The same vote of two thirds required for the presentation of the Amendment will pass the Act over the veto of the President. Once adopted, it will go into instant operation, without waiting for the uncertain concurrence of State Legislatures, and without provoking local strife so wearisome to the country. The States will not be turned into political caldrons, and the Democratic party will have no pudding-stick with which to stir the bubbling mass.
I do not depart from the proprieties of this occasion, when I show how completely the course I now propose harmonizes with the requirements of the political party to which I belong. Believing most sincerely that the Republican party, in its objects, is identical with country and with mankind, so that in sustaining it I sustain these comprehensive charities, I cannot willingly see this agency lose the opportunity of confirming its supremacy. You need votes in Connecticut, do you not? There are three thousand fellow-citizens in that State ready at the call of Congress to take their place at the ballot-box. You need them also in Pennsylvania, do you not? There are at least fifteen thousand in that great State waiting for your summons. Wherever you most need them, there they are; and be assured they will all vote for those who stand by them in the assertion of Equal Rights. In standing by them you stand by all that is most dear in the Republic.
Pardon me,—but, if you are not moved by considerations of justice under the Constitution, then I appeal to that humbler motive which is found in the desire for success. Do this and you will assure the triumph of all that you can most desire. Party, country, mankind, will be elevated, while the Equal Rights of All will be fixed on a foundation not less enduring than the Rock of Ages.
The bill offered by Mr. Sumner as a substitute for the original joint resolution was rejected; and the latter, embodying the proposed Amendment to the Constitution, failed for want of the requisite two-thirds of the votes cast,—these standing, Yeas 31, Nays 27.