One difficulty met with in our study of the distribution of the finds of extinct vertebrates in North Carolina, as elsewhere, arises from carelessness in recording and preserving proper data. In several cases here to be considered, no more is known than that a fossil has been found in a certain county. Happily, more is known in many other cases.
Examination shows that no fossil vertebrates are known to have been found in North Carolina within the area of the Coharie formation, but that mastodons have been met with in the areas of all four of the other formations as laid down in Stephenson’s map, plate XIII of the work cited above. Horse remains, too, seem to have occurred within all the areas last noted. This does not mean necessarily that these remains were buried in the corresponding formations. A mastodon may have lived long after the Sunderland was laid down and his remains have become buried in some isolated deposit, say of Pamlico times; or, the remains may be found within the area of Pamlico, but really buried in underlying Chowan. Each case must be decided on the evidence bearing on it.
Mention is made on page [155] of the finding of a tooth of Elephas columbi about 9 miles below Wilmington. Whether this was buried in Pamlico deposits close along Cape Fear River, in Chowan deposits which prevail there, or beneath these, in Wicomico, it is impossible to say. A short distance below this place was found a tooth of Mammut americanum.
On page [190] is given an account of the discovery of a tooth of Equus leidyi in what was supposed to be Miocene marl in the vicinity of Elizabethtown, on Cape Fear River, in Bladen County. Miller (op. cit., p. 248) states that the Pleistocene about Elizabethtown rests usually directly on the Cretaceous, but that south of the town are found some patches of Miocene marls. The region about this town is mostly occupied by the Sunderland formation, but the Wicomico extends up the river far above the place. It is, however, mapped as lying mostly on the north side of the river. It seems pretty certain that the horse-tooth occurred in the Sunderland, probably at its base.
Mastodon remains, as stated on page [115], have been found in Pender County, but where is not known. Along the coast is a narrow strip of Pamlico. The southeastern half of the county is occupied by the Chowan, the northwestern by the Wicomico.
Mastodon teeth have been found in Duplin County, but there is no record as to exact locality, depth, or matrix. The southeastern two-thirds of the county is covered by deposits of the Wicomico, the northwestern third by Sunderland. The mastodon probably belongs to one or the other of these. The Pleistocene deposits are, however, underlain by Tertiary rocks, and possibly the mastodon came from these and belongs to a different genus.
On page [116] will be found an account of remains of a mastodon, probably Mammut americanum, which was found near Jacksonville, in Onslow County. Three of the supposed Pleistocene formations are found near Jacksonville. The Pamlico comes up the New River quite to the town. Immediately at the town is (following Stephenson’s map) the Chowan. The southeastern border of the Wicomico comes down nearly to the town. In which of the three areas the teeth were discovered we do not know. A case is here furnished which illustrates the need of most accurate observation and record of locality, depth, and character of materials.
As stated on page [116], teeth and tusks of Mammut americanum have been obtained at Maysville, Jones County. The writer does not know exactly the place where the remains were discovered. The region about Maysville is occupied by the Chowan formation, but the Pamlico sends an extension up White Oak River as far as Maysville.
Remains of both Mammut and Elephas have been reported from Carteret County. In 1828 (see p. [117]) Elisha Mitchell stated that remains of the elephant and mastodon had been met with in digging the Clubfoot and Harlow Canal. This canal passed from Neuse River to Newport River. In 1876 (Senate Ex. Doc. No. 35, 44th Congr., p. 17) S. T. Abert transcribed, from an earlier report made by Professor Olmstead, a geological section taken in this canal. The excavation went to a depth of 16 feet. The uppermost of the four layers consisted of the peaty mold usually found in the swamp. The next layer was made up of a yellowish-brown potter’s clay. The third layer consisted of sand and was full of sea-shells and fossil remains of “mammoths” (mastodons) and elephants. The shells belonged to species now found near Cape Lookout, principally conch, scallop, and clam. The layer below this was blue clay. In the case here presented there can hardly be a doubt that the stratum containing the shells and the bones belonged to a Pleistocene formation older than that assigned to the Pamlico.
On page [145] is described a tooth of Elephas primigenius, dredged up in Core Creek, forming part of the Inland Waterway in Carteret County. The conclusion seems unavoidable that this boreal animal had been driven to this southern latitude during one of the glacial stages, and one naturally thinks of the latest one, the Wisconsin; but it may have been at a much earlier time. A mastodon jaw has been secured in the same canal.