At the Orange County Fair, September 21st, 22nd, 1858.
In Show Class for Aged Stallions.
| First prize was awarded to Edsall's Hambletonian (Alexander's Abdallah) by Hambletonian | J. S. Edsall |
| Second prize—Washington | J. D. Veruol |
| Third prize—Harry Clay by Cassius M. Clay | J. D. Sayer |
In the Speed Classes for 4 Yr. Old Mares.
| First prize—Lady Howard by Hambletonian. | J. W. Hoyt | Time, 3.02 |
| Second prize—Alida by Hambletonian. | M. F. Ten Eyck | " 3.03 |
Best 5 Yr. Olds.
| First prize—Lady Banker by Hambletonian. | R. Galloway | Time, 2.31 |
| Second prize—Frank Dickerson by Hambletonian. | Geo. Payne | " 2.53-1/2 |
| Third prize—Jenny Hawkins by American Star. | J. J. McNally | " 2.54 |
Best 3 Yr. Old Stallion.
| First prize—Guy Miller by Hambletonian. | R. F. Galloway | Time, 3.00 |
| Second prize—Young Abdallah. | Geo Payne | " 3.24 |
| Third prize—Index. | Seely C. Roe | " 3.26 |
Best 4 Yr. Old Stallion.