| First prize—Hambletonian 2nd (Volunteer) by Hambletonian | Joseph Hetzel | Time, 2.57 |
| Second prize—Abdallah by Hambletonian. | Wm. M. Rysdyk | " 3.04-1/2 |
| Third prize—Tom Thumb (Wild Warrior). | Robt. Carr | " 3.10 |
Best 5 Yr. Old Stallion.
| First prize—Harry Clay by Cassius M. Clay. | J. P. Sayer | Time. 2.56 |
| Second prize—C. M. Clay | C. J. Brown | " 3.14 |
Stallions Free for All.
| First prize—American Star. | Edmund Seely | Time, 2.50 |
| Second prize—Harry Clay by Cassius M. Clay. | J. P. Sayer | " 2.53 |
| Third prize—Edsall's Hambletonian (Alexander's Abdallah) by Hambletonian. | J. S. Edsall | " 2.54 |
Mares Free for All.
| First prize—Mary Hoyt by American Star | J. W. Hoyt | Time, 2.36-1/2 |
| Second prize—Goshen Maid by American Star | Edmund Seely | " 2.44-1/2 |
| Third prize—Lyd by Bolivar. | Amos Ryerson | " 2.52 |
The above summaries show that in every speed class for colts, the get of Hambletonian were the winners and one of the very first of that horse's get, Edsall's Hambletonian (Alexander's Abdallah) in stallion class for show, was awarded first prize.
It is of interest to note that in the class for mares of all ages, Mary Hoyt's record of 2.36-1/2 was the first record performance better than 2.40 on the Goshen track and she was in the hands of the best horseman of his time, J. W. Hoyt. This performance shows the real value of the colt records, they having no track education and no modern appliances such as boots, etc.
Mr. Joseph Hetzel, a farmer near Florida, related to the writer years later, that he had no idea of competing in the speed class with his colt Hambletonian 2nd (Volunteer), and so informed inquirers at Goshen, yet when it was confided to him that it had been said "he dare not," "his Dutch was aroused," he borrowed a skeleton wagon and harness and at his request the judges permitted him to start behind the other entries. Mr. Hetzel made no attempt for the lead until passing the stand the second time when he gave his colt his head, soon obtaining a commanding lead and finishing more than seven seconds ahead of his nearest competitor. Such an ovation as this church deacon and his colt received from an enthusiastic and admiring assemblage is seldom witnessed.