First Critic.
"His work unequal as we read,
We think upon the whole
This author almost would succeed
If nearer to his goal."
Second Critic.
"His serious pages suit us well,
Revealing thought and heart;
But he is quite unbearable
When trying to be smart!"
Third Critic.
"Some sprightly pages from his pen
With pleasure we have read;
But if he moralises, then
He's heavier than lead!"
Fourth Critic.
"We by the eye of faith can see—
It isn't from his books—
He is not such a fool as he
Invariably looks."
Fifth Critic.
"This author's pages needs must thrill
A sympathetic mind,—
Of subtle knowledge, tender skill,
Deep pathos, wit refined."