+ + N. Y. Times. 11: 319. My. 19, ’06. 810w. (Review of v. 14.)
“The present is one of the most valuable of the volumes in ‘The American nation’ series.” R. L. S.
+ + + N. Y. Times. 11: 341. My. 26, ’06. 850w. (Review of v. 15.) + + N. Y. Times. 11: 491. Ag. 4, ’06. 600w. (Review of v. 16.)
“Each of these volumes, while giving evidence of thorough research and acquaintance with the subject, is devoid of noticeable features.”
+ + N. Y. Times. 11: 894. D. 22, ’06. 690w. (Review of v. 17 and 18.)
“Though ... the presentation is not always as ample as might be desired, his book should be cordially welcomed by students of Revolutionary history.”
+ + – Outlook. 81: 281. S. 30, ’05. 260w. (Review of v. 8.)
“From the literary standpoint his work does not reach any high level. On the score of accuracy, lucidity, impartiality, perspective, and perception of cause and effect, little fault is to be found.”
+ + Outlook. 82: 374. F. 17, ’06. 370w. (Review of v. 11.)
“He has, generally speaking, succeeded in investing the well-known facts with a fresh interest. His pages are rich in acute analysis, suggestive comment, and clear-cut portraiture; his style is lucid, direct, and dignified, his tone judicial.”