| 1839 | R. Menzies, F. W. Menzies, R. S. Fox (cox.), University. |
| 1840 | O. B. Barttelot, Corpus Christi; E. Royds, Brasenose; T. Evett (cox.), Corpus Christi. |
| 1841 | H. E. C. Stapylton, W. Bolland, J. H. Griffiths (cox.), University. |
| 1842 | W. Wilberforce, G. E. Hughes, G. B. Lewis (cox.), Oriel. |
| 1843 | M. Haggard, W. H. Milman, F. J. Prout (cox.), Christ Church. |
| 1844 | M. Haggard, W. H. Milman, F. J. Prout (cox.), Christ Church. |
| 1845 | M. Haggard, W. H. Milman, C. J. Fuller (cox.), Christ Church. |
| 1846 | A. Milman, E. C. Burton, H. Ingram (cox.), Christ Church. |
| 1847 | W. G. Rich, A. Milman, Christ Church. |
| 1848 | T. H. Michel, C. H. Steward, Oriel. |
| 1849 | E. M. Clissold, Exeter; J. W. Chitty, Balliol. |
| 1850 | J. C. Bengoagh, Oriel; J. W. Chitty, Balliol. |
| 1851 | R. Greenall, R. Prescot, Brasenose. |
| 1852 | W. F. Short, W. L. Rogers, New. |
| 1853 | C. Cadogan, Christ Church; W. F. Short, New. |
| 1854 | C. Cadogan, Christ Church; W. F. Short, New. |
| 1855 | A. F. Lonsdale, E. Warre, Balliol. |
| 1856 | E. Warre, A. F. Lonsdale, Balliol. |
| 1857 | P. W. Phillips, J. Arkell, Pemberton. |
| 1858 | T. B. Shaw-Hellier, Brasenose; F. Ho’comb, Wadham. |
| 1859 | B. de B. Russell, R. F. Clarke, St. John’s. |
| 1860 | W. B. Woodgate, H. F. Baxter, Brasenose. |
| 1861 | W. Champneys, W. B. Woodgate, Brasenose. |
| 1862 | R. Shepherd, W. B. Woodgate, Brasenose. |
| 1863 | C. P. Roberts, M. Brown, Trinity. |
| 1864 | C. P. Roberts, M. Brown, Trinity. |
| 1865 | R. T. Raikes, Merton; M. Brown, Trinity. |
| 1866 | G. H. Swinney, G. H. Morrell, Merton. |
| 1867 | W. C. Crofts, F. Crowder, Brasenose. |
| 1868 | A. V. Jones, Exeter; W. C. Crofts, Brasenose. |
| 1869 | F. Pownall, A. V. Jones, Exeter. |
| 1870 | J. Mair, St. Alb.; C. J. Vesey, St. John’s. |
| 1871 | J. W. M’C. Bunbury, Brasenose; A. G. P. Lewis, University. |
| 1872 | H. J. Preston, A. S. Daniel, University. |
| 1873 | W. Farrer, Balliol; M. Farrer, Brasenose. |
| 1874 | M. Farrer, H. Benson, Brasenose. |
| 1875 | H. J. Preston, University; Edwardes-Moss, Brasenose. |
| 1876 | H. M. Marriott, T. C. Edwardes-Moss, Brasenose. |
| 1877 | D. J. Cowles, W. L. Giles, St. John’s. |
| 1878 | T. C. Edwardes-Moss, Brasenose; W. A. Ellison, University. |
| 1879 | C. R. L. Fletcher, F. P. Bulley, Magdalen. |
| 1880 | E. Staniland, Magdalen; L. R. West, Christ Church. |
| 1881 | C. Lowry, R. de Haviland, Corpus. |
| 1882 | G. C. Bourne, New; C. H. Sharpe, Hertford. |
| 1883 | A. G. Shortt, A. B. Shaw, Christ Church. |
| 1884 | W. S. Unwin, Magdalen; J. Reade, Brasenose. |
| 1885 | H. McLean, D. H. McLean, New. |
| 1886 | H. McLean, D. H. McLean, New. |
| 1887 | M. E. Bradford, F. W. Douglas, Christ Church. |
| 1841 | T. T. Peocock, Merton | 1865 | J. Rickaby, Brasenose |
| 1842 | H. Morgan, Christ Church | 1866 | W. L. Freeman, Merton |
| 1843 | Sir F. E. Scott, Christ Church | 1867 | W. C. Crofts, Brasenose |
| 1844 | Sir F. E. Scott, Christ Church | 1868 | W. C. Crofts, Brasenose |
| 1845 | J. W. Conant, St. John’s | 1869 | A. C. Yarborough, Lincoln |
| 1846 | E. S. Moon, Magdalen | 1870 | A. C. Yarborough, Lincoln |
| 1847 | E. C. Burton, Christ Church | 1871 | J. W. McC. Bunbury, Brasenose |
| 1848 | D. Wauchope, Wadham | 1872 | C. C. Knollys, Magdalen |
| 1849 | T. Erskine Clarke, Wadham | 1873 | J. B. Little, Christ Church |
| 1850 | T. Erskine Clarke, Wadham | 1874 | A. Michell, Oriel |
| 1851 | W. Heaven, Trinity | 1875 | L. C. Cholmeley, Magdalen |
| 1852 | H. M. Irving, Balliol | 1876 | D. J. Cowles, St. John’s |
| 1853 | W. F. Short, New | 1877 | T. C. Edwardes-Moss, Brasenose |
| 1854 | W. F. Short, New | 1878 | J. Lowndes, Hertford |
| 1855 | E. Warre, Balliol | 1879 | J. Lowndes, Hertford |
| 1856 | E. Warre, Balliol | 1880 | H. S. Chesshire, Worcester |
| 1857 | R. W. Risley, Exeter | 1881 | H. S. Chesshire, Worcester |
| 1858 | R. W. Risley, Exeter | 1882 | G. Q. Roberts, Hertford |
| 1859 | H. F. Baxter, Brasenose | 1883 | A. E. Staniland, Magdalen |
| 1860 | T. R. Finch, Wadham | 1884 | W. S. Unwin, Magdalen |
| 1861 | W. B. Woodgate, Brasenose | 1885 | W. S. Unwin, Magdalen |
| 1862 | W. B. Woodgate, Brasenose | 1886 | F. O. Wethered, Christ Church |
| 1863 | J. E. Parker, University | 1887 | G. Nicholls, Magdalen |
| 1864 | E. B. Michell, Magdalen | | |