| 1844 | T. W. Brooks and W. P. Cloves, First Trinity. |
| 1845 | S. Vincent and E. P. Wolstenholme, First Trinity. |
| 1846 | T. M. Hoare and T. M. Gisborne, St. John’s. |
| 1847 | S. Vincent and W. Maule, First Trinity. |
| 1848 | A. B. Dickson and W. L. G. Bagshawe, Third Trinity. |
| 1849 | A. Baldry, First Trinity, and W. L. G. Bagshawe, Third Trinity. |
| 1850 | J. B. Cane and C. Hudson, St. John’s. |
| 1851 | E. Macnaghten, First Trinity, and F. W. Johnson, Third Trinity. |
| 1852 | W. S. Langmore and E. Hawley, Sidney. |
| 1853 | R. Gordon and J. G. Barlee, Christ’s. |
| 1854 | R. C. Galton, First Trinity, and H. Blake, Corpus. |
| 1855 | H. Blake, Corpus, and J. Wright, St. John’s. |
| 1856 | R. Gordon and P. H. Wormald, Christ’s. |
| 1857 | R. E. Thompson and N. Royds, First Trinity. |
| 1858 | R. Beaumont and F. W. Holland, Third Trinity. |
| 1859 | D. Ingles, First Trinity, and J. P. Ingham, Third Trinity. |
| 1860 | R. P. Fitzgerald, Trinity Hall, and J. P. Ingham, Third Trinity. |
| 1861 | A. D. A. Burney and A. M. Channell, First Trinity. |
| 1862 | J. G. Chambers, Third Trinity, and R. Neave, Trinity Hall. |
| 1863 | R. A. Kinglake and J. R. Selwyn, Third Trinity. |
| 1864 | R. A. Kinglake and W. R. Griffiths, Third Trinity. |
| 1865 | J. R. Selwyn and W. R. Griffiths, Third Trinity. |
| 1866 | W. R. Griffiths, Third Trinity, and J. U. Bourke, First Trinity. |
| 1867 | E. Hopkinson and H. Herbert, Christ’s. |
| 1868 | C. Pitt-Taylor and J. Blake-Humphrey, Third Trinity. |
| 1869 | L. P. Muirhead and E. Phelps, Sidney. |
| 1870 | John B. Close and G. L. Rives, First Trinity. |
| 1871 | James B. Close and John B. Close, First Trinity. |
| 1872 | H. E. Rhodes and E. Hoskyns, Jesus. |
| 1873 | P. J. Hibbert and E. Sawyer, Lady Margaret. |
| 1874 | G. F. Armytage and C. D. Shafto, Jesus. |
| 1875 | W. B. Close and G. C. Dicker, First Trinity. |
| 1876 | T. E. Hockin and C. Gurdon, Jesus. |
| 1877 | J. G. Pinder and C. O. L. Riley, Caius. |
| 1878 | A. H. Prior and H. Sanford, Lady Margaret. |
| 1879 | J. A. Watson-Taylor, Magdalene, and T. E. Hockin, Jesus. |
| 1880 | L. R. Jones and E. Priest, Jesus. |
| 1881 | J. F. Keiser and S. P. Smith, First Trinity. |
| 1882 | W. K. Hardacre and F. C. Meyrick, Trinity Hall. |
| 1883 | C. J. Bristowe and F. C. Meyrick, Trinity Hall. |
| 1884 | P. S. Propert and S. Swann, Trinity Hall. |
| 1885 | R. H. Coke and S. Swann, Trinity Hall. |
| 1886 | S. D. Muttlebury and C. Barclay, Third Trinity. |
| 1887 | S. D. Muttlebury and C. T. Barclay, Third Trinity. |
| 1837 | Berney, Lady Margaret | 1863 | J. G. Chambers, Third Trin. |
| 1838 | Antrobus, Lady Margaret | 1864 | G. D. Redpath, First Trinity |
| 1839 | Vincent, Lady Margaret | 1865 | H. Watney, Lady Margaret |
| 1840 | Shadwell, Lady Margaret | 1866 | G. Shann, First Trinity |
| 1841 | Shadwell (no challenger) | 1867 | G. H. Wright, First Trinity |
| 1842 | Denman, First Trinity | 1868 | E. Phelps, Sidney, and F. E. Marshall, First Trinity |
| 1843 | Thompson, Peterhouse | 1869 | No race; postponed to 1870 |
| 1844 | Miles, Third Trinity | 1870 | J. B. Close, First Trinity |
| 1845 | Cloves, First Trinity | 1870 | J. H. D. Goldie, Lady Mar. |
| 1846 | Maule, First Trinity | 1871 | C. W. Benson, Third Trinity |
| 1847 | Bagshawe, Third Trinity | 1872 | James B. Close, First Trinity |
| 1848 | Bagot, Second Trinity | 1873 | A. C. Dicker, Lady Margaret |
| 1849 | Miller, Third Trinity | 1874 | W. B. Close, First Trinity |
| 1850 | Cowle and Hudson[22] | 1875 | S. A. Saunders, Second Trinity |
| 1851 | Macnaghten, First Trinity | 1876 | J. C. Fenn, First Trinity |
| 1852 | Courage, First Trinity | 1877 | T. W. Barker, First Trinity |
| 1853 | Galton, First Trinity | 1878 | H. Sandford, Lady Margaret |
| 1854 | Wright, Lady Margaret | 1879 | Prior, Lady Margaret |
| 1855 | Salter, Trinity Hall | 1880 | J. Keiser, First Trinity |
| 1856 | Beaumont, Third Trinity | 1881 | J. C. Fellowes, First Trinity |
| 1857 | Busk, First Trinity | 1882 | F. W. Fox, First Trinity |
| 1858 | Ingles, First Trinity | 1883 | S. Swann, Trinity Hall |
| 1859 | Faley, Lady Margaret | 1884 | F. J. Pitman, Third Trinity |
| 1860 | Channell, First Trinity | 1885 | J. M. Cowper-Smith, First Trinity |
| 1861 | J. C. Hawkshaw, Third Trinity | 1886 | J. C. Gardner, Emmanuel |
| 1862 | C. B. Lawes, Third Trinity | 1887 | C. B. P. Bell, Trinity Hall |