[29] I published a criticism of this case in the London Economist, December 1, 1883.

[30] Quoted by Taussig: “History of the Existing Tariff,” 73.

[31] Illustrations of this are presented without number. Here is the most recent one: “The [silk] masters [of Lyons, France] look to the government for relief by a reduction of the duty on cotton yarn, or the right to import all numbers duty free for export after manufacture. With the present tariffs, they maintained, which is no doubt true, that they cannot compete with the Swiss and German makers. But the Rouen cotton spinners oppose the demand of the Lyons silk manufacturers, and protest that they will be ruined if the latter are allowed to procure their material from abroad. The Lyons weavers assert that they are being ruined because they cannot.”—(Economist, 1885, p. 815.) The cotton men won in the Chamber of Deputies, July 23, 1885.

[32] Independent, August 16, 1888.

[33] In Good Cheer for April, 1886, p. 7.

[34] Address at a dinner of the committee on Tariff Reform of the Reform Club in the city of New York, June 2, 1906.

[35] Leslie’s Weekly, August 20, 1896.

[36] Leslie’s Weekly, September 3, 1896.

[37] Leslie’s Weekly, September 10, 1896.

[38] Leslie’s Weekly, September 17, 1896.